Bangladesh2005 INVESTMENT CLIMATE STATEMENT -- BANGLADESH
OPENNESS TO FOREIGN INVESTMENT
The stated policy of the Government of Bangladesh (BDG) is to pursue foreign investment actively, and it has enacted a number of policies to this end. There are no distinctions between foreign and domestic private investors regarding investment incentives or export and import policies. Incentives for investors include: 100% ownership in most sectors; tax holidays; reduced import duties on capital machinery and spares; duty-free imports for 100% exporters; and tax exemptions. The 2004 budget contained a $100 million subsidy for the agriculture sector. There are few performance requirements, and these do not generally present a problem for foreign investors. Customs bonded warehouses assist exporters. Free repatriation of profits is allowed and is almost fully convertible on the current account. Although discrimination against foreign investors is not widespread, some discriminatory policies and regulations exist. For example, advertisements for imported products are assessed a 60% advertising surcharge for television spots on state-owned television.
Major laws affecting foreign investment are the Foreign Private Investment Act of 1980, the Industrial Policy of 1999, the Bangladesh Export Processing Zones Authority Act of 1980, the Companies Act, 1994, and the Telecommunications Act, 2001. Trade has been gradually liberalized over the past five years, although import duties and supplemental taxes remain high and constitute the largest single sources of Government revenue. The FY2004 budget reduced the maximum import duty rate by 5%. The budget also reduced the maximum supplementary duty on imports of products of general nature at 30% from 75%.
No prior approval is required for foreign direct investment except registration with the BDG Board of Investment (BOI). Registration with BOI is necessary to obtain benefits such as importing machinery at concessionary duty rates or importing items on the "restricted list." BOI also administers the approval of foreign loans and technology remittances on behalf of Bangladesh Bank. BDG authority, however, for dealing with foreign investments is fragmented. BOI, frequently touted as a one-stop shop for all investors, is set up only to register investors in industrial projects outside the export processing zones (EPZs) and assist them with tax inquiries, land acquisition, utility hook-ups, and incorporation. The corresponding EPZ authority is the Bangladesh Export Processing Zones Authority. Investors in power, mineral resources, and telecommunications must seek approval from the corresponding BDG ministries. Although BOI is housed organizationally in the Prime Minister’s Office, regulatory and administrative powers remain vested in the line ministries, and thus BOI has not proved to be an effective advocate for foreign investors. The BDG has indicated it hopes to streamline BOI’s procedures and find ways to attract new foreign investment to Bangladesh. The foreign investors in Bangladesh appreciates the leadership of the current BOI Chairman, who has been working hard to make Bangladesh a convenient place for foreign investors and has been successful in many cases.
Privatization is another critical part of the BDG's stated economic reform policy. After assuming power in 2001, the present government prepared a list of 94 state-owned enterprises (SOEs) for privatization by the Privatization Commission (PC). The PC has privatized 18 SOEs during the last three years, including three large industries—the Adamjee Jute Mill, the country’s largest and most costly SOE, the Karnaphuli Chemical Mill, and the Chittagong Chemical Complex. Letters of Intent (LOI) have been issued to selected buyers for eight more SOEs, four of which are expected to go to closing in 2005. The PC has recently invited international tenders for sale of seven additional SOEs.
The BDG still resists privatizing utilities and opening critical sectors to full competition, though that is starting to change. Bangladesh allowed private sector entry in power generation and natural gas exploration, but efforts to grant autonomy in petroleum marketing and gas distribution have hit stumbling blocks. Biman Bangladesh Airlines tried to sell a large stake in its ownership, but could not find a willing partner. The Government used to provide telecom services exclusively, but now two private companies operate in rural telecom, and four firms are involved in cellular phone systems. There is continued talk of privatizing the Bangladesh Telephone and Telegraph Board, inland ports, and container and cargo handling. Government has provided licenses to ten new private operators to provide telephone services outside the capital city.
According to an UNCTAD report, FDI to Bangladesh averaged $7 million annually from 1990-1996, but increased to an annual average of $196.8 million from 1997-2000, primarily due to foreign investment in Bangladesh’s energy sector. In 2001, however, new FDI dropped 72% (to $78 million) from the previous year. In 2002 new FDI again dropped to $52 milli0on. But in 2003 the FDI jumped to $120 million.
Investors from the United States and other countries continue to show interest in Bangladesh. Investors report both positive and negative experiences. In 2004, an American health care firm was approved to invest $35 million in a project to refurbish, expand, operate and transfer a hospital in Dhaka. However, in 2003, another U.S. firm was unable, after five years, to gain approval for its $225 million container project, which would greatly increase the efficiency of the country’s primary port.
A number of foreign business delegations have visited Bangladesh to explore trade and investment opportunities, including from India, France, Turkey, Malaysia, Taiwan China, and Korea. The UAE Government invited the Chairman of Board of Investment to discuss investment opportunities in Bangladesh.
Foreigners often find that ministries request unnecessary licenses and permissions. Added to these difficulties are such problems as corruption, labor militancy, an uncertain law and order situation, poor infrastructure, inadequate commercial laws and courts, inconsistent respect for contract sanctity, and policy instability (i.e., policies being altered at the behest of special interests, and decisions taken by previous governments being overturned when a new government comes to power). To a lesser extent, difficulty in attracting foreign investment also results from Bangladesh's image as an impoverished and undeveloped country subject to frequent and devastating natural disasters. This is a partial misconception, as the annual floods, which inundate up to one-third of Bangladesh, are vital for agricultural production each year. Prior to political instability and warfare in the 1950s, Bangladesh had been one of the wealthiest regions in Asia and its land is still considered among the most fertile in the world.
CONVERSION AND TRANSFER POLICIES The BDG's foreign exchange reserves have increased steadily from a low of about $1 billion in November 2001 to over $3 billion in November 2004. This was primarily due to Finance Ministry initiatives to increase the flow of remittances from overseas workers through official banking channels. As a result, remittances now total approximately $3 billion annually. The taka currently trades at about 61 per dollar. Foreign currency also is widely available on the parallel (curb) market at a minimal premium. Inflation has risen recently to a still-manageable 6.21%.
EXPROPRIATION AND COMPENSATION
In the years immediately following independence in 1971, widespread nationalization resulted in Government ownership of over 90% of fixed assets in the modern manufacturing sector, as well as all banking and insurance interests, except those in foreign (but non-Pakistani) hands. Domestically owned cotton textiles, jute, and sugar manufacturing units, none of which was owned by foreigners, were placed under Government control. However, the Foreign Investment Act of 1980 has forbidden nationalization or expropriation without adequate compensation, and there have been no instances of foreign property expropriation since the Foreign Investment Act was passed.
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT
A fundamental impediment to investment in Bangladesh is a weak and slow legal system in which the enforceability of contracts is uncertain. The judicial system does not provide for interest to be charged in tort judgments, and hence there is no penalty for delaying proceedings. While the Supreme Court and High Court (appellate level courts) are independent, the lower courts are part of the executive branch of government. The Supreme Court issued directive requiring the government to separate the lower courts from the executive branch, but no legislation has been passed yet to make the lower courts independent. It is widely acknowledged that in the lower courts, where cases are first brought, corruption is a serious problem. Nevertheless, the highest levels of the judiciary, including the Supreme Court, have retained a reputation for fairness and competence. This has meant that, at least at the appellate level, the outcome of commercial cases is usually determined on merit.Bangladesh is a signatory to the International Convention for the Settlement of Disputes (ICSID) and it acceded (on May 6, 1992) to the United Nations Convention for the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. A provision of the U.S.-Bangladesh Bilateral Investment Treaty gives procedures for referring irresolvable investment disputes to ICSID for third-party settlement. In any case, the ability of the Bangladeshi judicial system to enforce its own awards is weak, and there is no reason to think enforcement of foreign judgments would be stronger. The Bangladesh Export Promotion Bureau is sometimes helpful in assisting in dispute settlement of export-related transactions. Major Bangladeshi trade and business associations can also be helpful in assisting in transaction disputes. PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS/INCENTIVES
BDG industrial policies emphasize manufacturing and labor-intensive industries that use local inputs. There are a variety of subsidies and other incentives provided to different industrial sectors, primarily the export sectors and, to a certain extent, import substitution sectors. The BDG also provides loans at concessional rates through its nationalized banks and government-owned development banks for exports, cottage industries, and agriculture. These incentives are available to both domestic and foreign investors.
There is a provision for full duty drawback at the time of export on imported raw materials used in manufacturing products for export. In lieu of the duty drawback, exporters can use the special bonded warehouse facility to import raw material duty free. In order to qualify for the duty drawback and special bonded warehouse schemes, the exported item must have at least 25% domestic content. The BDG also provides direct subsidies to export-oriented ready-made garment manufacturers if their exports use 100% locally manufactured raw materials or have paid duty on imported raw materials. This cash incentive, designed to encourage “backward linkages” in the textile sector, amounts to 10% of the export value. A similar 5% export cash assistance incentive, designed to encourage exports with domestic content, is available for jute and 15% for leather products. -- A 50% rebate for taxable income generated from export earnings
-- Income tax exemptions for export earnings from handicraft and cottage industries
-- Tax holidays of 5-7 years, depending on location, for new industrial enterprises
-- A 10-year tax holiday for enterprises in the EPZs
-- Accelerated depreciation for enterprises not eligible for a tax holiday
-- Income tax exemption for 15 years for power projects
As of June 2004, the World Trade Organization had not received any notifications alleging Bangladeshi violations of the Agreement on Trade-Related Investment Measures.
RIGHT TO PRIVATE OWNERSHIP AND ESTABLISHMENT
Foreign and domestic private entities can establish and own, operate, and dispose of interests in most types of business enterprises. Five sectors, however, are reserved for government investment:
-- Arms, ammunition, and defense equipment and machinery
-- Production of nuclear energy
-- Security printing and mining
-- Forestry in the reserved forest areas
-- Air transportation (except air cargo and international air transportation) and railways
Although inefficient SOEs continue to stifle Bangladesh’s potential for greater economic performance, the closing of several enterprises shows that the Government can take necessary action to push for overdue economic restructuring.
PROTECTION OF PROPERTY RIGHTS
Although land, whether for purchase or lease, is often critical for investment and as security for loans, antiquated real property laws guarantee chaos. Land registration records are unreliable. Parties avoid registering mortgages, liens, and encumbrances because certain stamp duties and charges have been set at high levels. Instruments take effect from the date of execution, not the date of registration, so a bona fide purchaser can never be certain of title.
The BDG is progressing slowly in bringing its intellectual property rights laws into compliance with the World Trade Organization’s Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement. Parliament is expected to amend the country’s trademark, patent, and copyright legislation, following a lengthy inter-agency approval and clearance process. The government, however, allocates few resources to IPR enforcement, and is experiencing a worsening IPR situation. The prevention and punishment of IPR violations is very low in proportion to the number of infringements. The government also sets a poor example by failing to account fully for software in its tenders. A number of American firms, including film studios, manufacturers of consumer goods, and software firms, have reported violations of their intellectual property rights. Bangladesh is a member of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), and acceded to the Paris Convention on Intellectual Property in 1991.
TRANSPARENCY OF THE REGULATORY SYSTEM: LAWS AND PROCEDURES In practice, BDG laws and regulations and their implementation do not reduce distortions or impediments to investment, but create them. Unhelpful treatment of businesses by some BDG officials, coupled with other negatives in the investment climate, raise start-up and operational costs, add to risk, and tend to counteract the BDG's praiseworthy investment incentives. There is generally little opportunity for the private sector to comment on proposed regulations.
EFFICIENT CAPITAL MARKETS AND PORTFOLIO INVESTMENTForeign investors have access to local credit markets, but many seek offshore financing. If they finance locally, it is usually with a foreign bank branch. Four state-owned banks, known as nationalized commercial banks (NCBs), comprise nearly 50% of the banking sector’s total assets. The largest NCB has assets totaling approximately $4 billion. An estimated 30% of the country’s total asset base is non-performing, primarily because of long-outstanding debts to the NCBs. The World Bank has approved $250 million as International Development Association (IDA) soft loan to Bangladesh for the enterprise growth and bank modernization project. As a part of the process, a private management team from Price-Waterhouse Coopers, an international consulting firm, took charge of the Agrani Bank.
The private sector can receive financing from leasing companies and by issuing shares or debentures on the Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE) or the Chittagong Stock Exchange (CSE). All CSE-listed shares are also listed on the larger and older DSE. Among the world's smallest share markets, the privately-owned Dhaka Stock Exchange (established in 1954) lists 195 companies; the Chittagong Stock Exchange (established in 1995) lists 129. There was a large surge in the stock market in the summer and fall of 1996, but the market crashed late in the year and has yet to fully recover. Foreign portfolio investment, never more than $200 million, has virtually disappeared. Both the CSE (July 1998) and the DSE (August 1998) have automatic trading services. Incidents of politically directed damage to foreign projects or installations have occurred, although violence targeted against business concerns generally has been isolated and criminal, rather than political, in nature. Following U.S. military action in Iraq, a number of sizeable anti-American demonstrations occurred (between 10,000 and 80,000 participants.) A few of these demonstrations resulted in minor property damage to U.S.-affiliated businesses. Calls for boycotts of American goods and services had limited impact and ended following the war’s conclusion.
Extortion of money from businesses by thugs claiming political backing is common. Clashes between supporters of rival political parties and their student and youth wings, and even factions within the same party, are frequent occurrences. General strikes and blockades called by political parties mostly affect businesses by keeping workers away with the threat of violence and blocking transport, resulting in productivity losses. Vehicles and other property are at risk from vandalism or arson during such programs, and looting of shops has occurred. The perception of a general deterioration of law and order, believed to be largely due to corruption and politically sponsored criminal activity, is a matter of widespread concern among Bangladeshis and has dampened domestic investment. From late 2002 to early 2003, the Bangladesh military was deployed to assist civil law enforcement tackle crime.
Responding to public concern over law and order, the government in March 2004 authorized a special elite force, known as the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB), as part of its anti-crime initiative. The RAB is comprised of members of the armed forces, the police, and the Bangladesh Rifles and Ansars, both paramilitary groups. The RAB became operational in June 2004. While the RAB has been credited by many Bangladeshis with improving domestic law and order, more than 100 alleged notorious criminals have been "killed in crossfire" during shootouts with the RAB or have been "killed while trying to escape."
CORRUPTION The now defunct Bangladesh Bureau of Anti-Corruption Bureau (BAC) was notoriously subservient to the ruling party and corrupt. In February 2004, Parliament passed legislation to create an independent Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC), which was formally established in November 2004. Provisionally staffed with employees of its predecessor organization, the ACC was embroiled in personnel and other controversies within weeks of its formation.
BILATERAL INVESTMENT AGREEMENTS OPIC AND OTHER INVESTMENT INSURANCE PROGRAMS LABOR
Bangladesh has a population of about 140 million people. The formal employment sector in Bangladesh has an estimated 4.8 million workers, and an estimated 1.4 million (30%) of these workers are employed in public enterprises. An estimated 40 million workers are employed in agricultural jobs (increasing at 1% a year) and 20 million in non-agricultural jobs. Low official unemployment statistics obscure a huge and growing under-employment problem in Bangladesh. Bangladesh's comparative advantage in cheap labor for manufacturing is partially offset by low productivity, due to low skills, poor management, and inefficient infrastructure and machinery. Foreign managers report that Bangladeshi workers generally respond well to training.
Skilled Bangladeshis often seek and find employment in the Middle East and East Asia at substantially higher wages than they would receive in Bangladesh. Over the past 20 years, Bangladesh has become a reliable source of labor, and during FY2003, over $3 billion in foreign exchange was remitted to Bangladesh through official banking channels. Remittances have become an important source of foreign exchange in recent years, and now exceed aid provided in the form of concessional loans and grants.
All employers are expected to comply with the government's labor laws, which specify employment conditions, working hours, wage levels, leave policies, health and sanitary conditions, and compensation for injured workers. Freedom of association and the right to join unions is guaranteed in the Bangladesh constitution. There are over 6,300 registered trade unions in Bangladesh, with over 1.9 million union members. FOREIGN TRADE ZONES Approximately a dozen U.S. firms — mostly textile producers — are currently operating in Bangladesh EPZs. South Korea is the largest foreign investor in the Dhaka and Chittagong EPZs; Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, the United Kingdom, Sweden, Thailand, India, Malaysia, Germany, Taiwan, China, U.A.E., France, Italy, Denmark, Panama and Pakistan are the other foreign investors in the EPZs. The remaining EPZ industries are Bangladeshi. The U.S. is the top destination of exports from EPZs. Industries range from garments and textiles to electronics, sporting goods, steel chains, and services (including equipment leasing and container repairs and handling).
UNCTAD reports the following annual FDI inflows for Bangladesh since 1990 (in millions):
1990: $3.2 1997: $139.4 At present, the U.S. is the largest foreign investor in Bangladesh, with total fixed direct investment of nearly $1.4 billion, followed by Norway, Malaysia, Japan, and the United Kingdom. The second tier of investors is Singapore, India, Thailand, Hong Kong, Germany, and South Korea. Prior to 1995, the stock of U.S. investment in Bangladesh was estimated to be approximately $25 million in book value, including five manufacturers in the Chittagong EPZ, one life insurance company, banking operations of two U.S. commercial banks, and about 10 other U.S. service and marketing firms. Since 1995, 16 U.S. companies have invested in Bangladesh in the following sectors (in production & under implementation):
Sector Investment
|
