Daily Press Briefing - November 1, 2010
Index for Today's Briefing:
- Secretary Clinton Has Arrived in Malaysia/Met with Chinese State Councilor Dai on Saturday
- U.S. Congratulates Brazilian President-elect Dilma Rousseff
- U.S. Confirms Deaths of Two U.S. Citizens in Ciudad Juarez and Extends Condolences to Families
- U.S. Has Actively Assisted the Haitian Government in Improving its Response Capabilities to Natural Disasters and Stands Ready to Respond to Hurricane Tomas at Haiti's Request
- U.S. Strongly Condemns Events Leading to Taking of Hostages at Christian Church in Baghdad
- Special Envoy Scott Gration Meetings in Khartoum Today, in Juba Tomorrow
- Embassy in Sana'a Fully Engaged with Yemeni Authorities/U.S. Continues to Evaluate Assistance to Yemen/Works to Improve Yemen's Capabilities to Fight Terrorism
- MIDDLE EAST PEACE
- Conflict, Final Status Issues Can Be Resolved Only Through Direct Negotiation
- The U.S. Works with Norway/Host Governments to Protect Our Diplomatic Posts Around the World
- Killings of Americans in Mexico Being Investigated
- U.S. Hopeful Israel and Turkey Can Resume Cooperation
- Hikers Should be Released, Not Put on Trial/U.S. Would Welcome Opportunity for Mothers to Speak with Hikers
- State Was In Touch with Canadian Government Regarding Implementation of Plea Bargain in Omar Khadr Case/Exchange of Diplomatic Notes Paved Way
- U.S. Backs Japan on Northern Territories/Encourages Russia and Japan to Negotiate Peace Treaty
- U.S. Actively Involved in Moving Bosnia Toward Full Integration As a Country and With Europe
- U.S. Hopeful Referendum on Abyei Can Be Accomplished in Early January as Scheduled/Parties Should Prepare for Decisions on Abyei and South Sudan
- U.S. Encourages China to Discuss North Korean Provocations With North Korea/Ongoing Concern
- Additional Reporting Requirement for Reconstruction Funds/Cholera Outbreak Under Investigation
Daily Press Briefing
1:42 p.m. EDT
MR. CROWLEY: A thousand apologies for being late. Good afternoon and welcome to the Department of State. Just a couple of things to talk about before taking your questions. The Secretary has arrived in Malaysia, where tomorrow she’ll have meetings with a variety of Malaysian officials and also civil society. The only wrinkle in her schedule is the prime minister is ill, so that may make some last-minute adjustments, depending on his availability.
But over the weekend, the Secretary discussed with State Councilor Dai on Saturday a range of issues from implementation of sanctions on Iran to the way forward on North Korea, as well as preparations for the president’s – President Hu Jintao’s upcoming visit to the United States, and then Sunday and today, had a range of activities in Cambodia, all designed to deepen our engagement with Cambodia going forward.
Moving to Brazil, we congratulate President-elect Dilma Rousseff on her election. We also congratulate the millions of Brazilians who exercised their right to vote in both the first-round elections on October 3rd and in the runoff yesterday. The exemplary electoral process again illustrates Brazil’s longstanding respect for democratic governance, civil rights, and individual liberties, values that we share in common. We look forward to working with President-elect Rousseff to deepen our partnership and advance common goals for the benefit of our two peoples and the Americas.
Staying in the region, we can confirm the deaths of three U.S. citizens in Ciudad, Juarez. Two citizens were fatally shot early Sunday, close to the Zaragoza International Bridge. And in a separate incident, another U.S. citizen was fatally wounded in Ciudad, Juarez itself. First, we offer our condolences to the families of the victims. We have been in touch with those families and are providing all possible assistance, and we will support the Mexican Government in the investigation that is already underway.
And in Haiti, we are obviously focused on the potential threat that Hurricane Tomas potentially poses to Haiti. We have been actively assisting the government in improving its response capabilities to natural disasters, anticipating all this summer that Haiti remained at a significant risk of tropical storms. We have been helping the government prepare for these kinds of contingencies, communicating with the Haitian people about what to do in the event of a storm. And we stand ready to respond, should Tomas bear down on Haiti in the coming days. We’ve been working with MINUSTAH and other international partners. We have stockpiled relief commodities in concert with the International Organization for Migration, and we have activated a team of nine disaster response experts who will be prepared to deploy to Haiti tomorrow in anticipation of landfall we expect right now Thursday or Friday.
Turning to Iraq, we strongly condemn the events of Sunday which led to the taking of hostages at a Christian church in Baghdad and the loss of many innocent and vulnerable Iraqi lives. We mourn the loss of life and extend our condolences to the victims’ families, friends, and communities The events that unfolded on Sunday were particularly reprehensible, as a place of worship was specifically involved after a nearby robbery attempt was unsuccessful. The United States stands with the Government of Iraq and the people of Iraq as they continue to demonstrate courage and determination in battling terrorists that only want to move Iraq in the wrong direction.
And finally, before taking your questions, Special Envoy Scott Gration in Khartoum today met with several Sudanese officials, including Vice President Taha and presidential adviser Dr. Ghazi Salahuddin Atabani. He plans to travel to Juba tomorrow to meet with Southern Sudanese leaders. Among the topics discussed today, Special Envoy Gration informed Khartoum about the decision made by the President which was announced a few minutes ago extending sanctions against Sudan for another year.
MR. CROWLEY: Mm-hmm.
QUESTION: What is the State Department’s role from this point forward in dealing with – working with Yemen on counterterrorism and other – whether it be aid programs or any other programs, in light of what’s happened?
MR. CROWLEY: Ambassador Feierstein and the Embassy in Sana’a is fully engaged with the Yemeni authorities as it takes action in light of Friday’s incident. As you know, John Brennan at the White House has been in touch with President Saleh as well. We will continue to evaluate our ongoing assistance programs to Yemen. For the fiscal year just ended, total assistance to Yemen approached $300 million – about $296 million, to be more precise – which involves security, humanitarian, and bilateral assistance. We do expect the level of assistance to Yemen for this coming year to be roughly in the same ballpark, although obviously we will continue to evaluate how we can best support Yemen in its fight against al-Qaida in the Arabian Peninsula, which obviously has a dramatic impact on the United States.
QUESTION: When you say evaluating the program, do you mean you’re considering either expanding them or contracting them, based on what’s the trend of events?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, we’re not going to contract them. We think that the increasing investment in Yemen has paid dividends. If you look back on the trend over the past three or four years, we have steadily increased our assistance to Yemen to the level that I just mentioned to you. We believe that Yemen has made significant improvements in its security and counterterrorism capability, but obviously that stems from a still limited capacity that Yemen has. It’s the poorest country in the region, and our efforts are geared towards steadily increasing Yemen’s ability to deal with violent extremists who are a threat to Yemen as well as a threat to the United States.
QUESTION: But this review that you’re talking about, was that already underway prior to the package bomb incidence, or has that been – are you doing the review because of that incident?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, I wouldn’t call it a formal review. We will obviously – I mean, we are working with Yemen as a government in the aftermath of Friday’s episode, and I would say that we are pleased with the cooperation that Yemen has shown in the last 72 hours. And – but as we go forward, we’ll obviously learn from this incident, just as we learned from the Christmas Day bomber 10 months ago, and adapt our programs appropriately.
QUESTION: P.J., on that score, how can you really guarantee that the money the United States sends will be used by President Salih to do what the United States hopes he will do, which is to fight al-Qaida, as opposed to fighting his enemies – political or even physical enemies, which are the people who are engaged in that rebellion?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, the fact is that the Yemeni Government has done what we have asked it to do. Yemen is a very complex society. It’s got a history involving a former division of the country into north and south Yemen. It does have a variety of conflicts that are going on inside its borders. Yemen is sovereign and has to deal with what it believes to be threats to its own security.
We have worked with Yemen and we are satisfied that Yemen is paying close attention to the threat posed by al-Qaida in the Arabian Peninsula. It’s a threat to Yemen as opposed to – in addition to being a threat to the United States and others.
QUESTION: Just on the score of their cooperation, they have a history of apprehending people and then letting them go. Is that resolved in your mind or is that still an issue that needs work? And I’m thinking about people related to the bombing of the Cole, for instance.
MR. CROWLEY: Well, there is – again, let me go back to the issue of capacity. Yemen has a limited governmental capacity, and we have worked hard to improve its capabilities so that it can secure Yemen for its own people as well as for others.
There’s no question, as John Brennan mentioned in his comments yesterday, that while we have seen improvement, more has to be done, because I think we recognize that going back to the Cole 10 years ago, Yemen is still a country with limited capabilities. And that is why we are investing increasing aid to help Yemen not only on the security front, but part of the solution to Yemen is to help make improvements on the civil society and development front as well.
QUESTION: Do we know what the status of the investigation is within Yemen for finding the bomb maker? Like, how are they proceeding?
MR. CROWLEY: For that, probably a better question directed to the Department of Justice or to the White House. Obviously, they are leading this investigation. We will support this investigation both in our own counterterrorism activities as well as through the Embassy in Sana’a.
QUESTION: What is Secretary Clinton doing on this score?
MR. CROWLEY: I’m not aware that she’s had any particular conversations. She’s staying up on the intelligence that has come from this particular incident, but I’m not aware that she has made any specific calls at this point.
QUESTION: On the Middle East?
MR. CROWLEY: Are we – okay.
QUESTION: There are some reports that there will be a change of the peace envoy to the Middle East – Dennis Ross is going to replace Mitchell and American former ambassador to Israel is going to – is one of the – of those nominated for the --
MR. CROWLEY: Well, this is the monthly rumor about George Mitchell’s departure. I’m not aware of any plans for George Mitchell to depart.
QUESTION: But there is no departure? He’s not going to the --
MR. CROWLEY: Not to my knowledge.
QUESTION: Can I follow up on that, though?
MR. CROWLEY: You may.
QUESTION: His team, though, is getting smaller. There are several people that have left or are leaving. It’s been moving back to Washington. Can – is there any sign that you’re rethinking strategy and how to go about --
MR. CROWLEY: I know of one person who has left. Do you want --
QUESTION: One person’s left. There’s another rumored to be going to USAID shortly. That’s pretty far along. And there’s others that have come back from Washington – to Washington.
MR. CROWLEY: Well, without confirming that necessarily, to actually continue to work on developing the capabilities of the Palestinian Authority, which is fully consistent with what Senator Mitchell is doing.
QUESTION: But are there – are you rethinking strategy now, I mean, given that there’s – it’s been two years basically?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, I mean, we’re intensively trying to get the parties back in negotiations. So we believe that we have the right strategy, which is only through a direct negotiation can the parties actually resolve the conflict once and for all. What we need to see is actual movement by the parties back into direct negotiations, and that is something that we are still intensively trying to achieve.
QUESTION: P.J., same --
MR. CROWLEY: David.
QUESTION: -- same subject. Amr Moussa, the Arab League Secretary General, gave an interview over the weekend, a radio interview with Fox, and he said that although they still have confidence in the U.S.-led process, it’s time to think about alternatives. And he asked, rhetorically, what’s wrong with going to the United Nations to get some sort of a General Assembly or a Security Council declaration for a Palestinian state. Is – what is wrong with that, in your opinion?
MR. CROWLEY: It doesn’t solve the conflict. The only way to end the conflict is to resolve the final status issues. The only way to resolve the final status issues is through a direct negotiation. Unilateral declarations or unilateral actions on one side or the other does not end the conflict. That is our goal.
QUESTION: But a Security Council or a General Assembly vote of some sort wouldn’t be a unilateral act.
MR. CROWLEY: Well, again, you have – we have a process that involves multiple tracks. Our objective here is comprehensive peace in the Middle East. Comprehensive peace in the Middle East can only be resolved through direct negotiations where the parties agree to end the conflict.
QUESTION: Are you encouraging them not to go that way?
MR. CROWLEY: We are encouraging them to return to negotiations.
QUESTION: Former President Carter said that if you declare through the General Assembly a Palestinian state this will help the Palestinian to unify and it could be a building step for the negotiations. Do you disagree with this?
MR. CROWLEY: President Carter is entitled to his views.
QUESTION: Prime Minister Netanyahu is due to be in New Orleans next weekend and the President is going to be overseas. Do you expect that the prime minister will meet any other U.S. officials either here or in New Orleans on this trip? Specifically the Secretary or down the –
MR. CROWLEY: We have had a conversation with the prime minister’s office. So the Secretary, as you know, will be overseas for another week, but we are looking to see if their schedules will overlap and we just don’t know.
QUESTION: What do you mean by that? You mean, when she gets back to Washington or she would go to New York or what?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, again, there’s an interest in getting together, but right now we’ve got – we’re just checking to see how elastic the prime minister’s schedule is, how long he’s going to be in the United States.
MR. CROWLEY: How are you?
MR. CROWLEY: Welcome to the State Department.
QUESTION: Thank you. I’m not here every day, so I’ll just state my name. I have some questions about security around your embassies. You have something who is called the surveillance detection program. What’s the background for that?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, the surveillance detection program is something that we’ve put in place over the last decade. We recognize that our posts around the world are prospective targets and tragically there’s a lot of intelligence and actual attacks to back that up, not the least of which were the bombings in East Africa a decade ago. So we work with the host government to do everything that we can to protect our diplomatic posts around the world, but including in Norway.
QUESTION: And you have a database called SIMAS who is connected to this program. Who can end up there?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, we have cooperation across our posts. We share information both with host governments and across our posts. It is possible when you look at a networked entity like al-Qaida that they might be casing a post in Europe, in the Middle East, in Africa, and so we have a database that shares intelligence and assessment – ongoing assessment of threats.
QUESTION: In Norway, are these activities cleared with the Norwegian authorities?
MR. CROWLEY: I’m sorry?
QUESTION: In Norway, are these activities cleared with the Norwegian authorities?
MR. CROWLEY: Yes. All of our activities in Norway are fully consistent with and with the cooperation of the host nation government.
QUESTION: P.J., on those Americans who were killed in Mexico, what’s the State Department understanding of how exactly the Americans were killed? And also in Arizona, there was this recent case of a beheading of a person. Is there – some people are quite concerned saying that this drug violence has really hit home when you have people being decapitated in the United States. Anything that the United States is doing? I know Secretary Clinton watches this –
MR. CROWLEY: Let’s be careful, Jill, that we don’t throw lots of things in a single basket. We have tragically three killings south of the border. They are being investigated. At this point, I don’t know that we can really assess what happened. You go back to some incidents that happened early this year, tragically, and in some of those cases these might have been deliberate actions. In other cases they might have been people in the wrong place at the wrong time. Yes, you do have a case of a death in Arizona that is being investigated by local authorities and, again, I’m not aware that there’s a specific theory of the case yet as to what happened with that tragic death.
QUESTION: Can I ask a similar question? There was a case of a shooting last Thursday where an American citizen was shot by the Mexican army. The details, I guess, at the time were unclear of why he was shot. There was a vehicle he was traveling in that allegedly shot at the patrol and they returned fire. Do you have any details on the case and –
MR. CROWLEY: We don’t. I’ll see what we know about that.
QUESTION: I appreciate it.
QUESTION: Going back to the Middle East. Late Friday and Saturday headlines of the Israeli media was Israel now major threat for Turkish national security. And on the other hand, countries like Syria and Iran are off the list now for Turkey. My question is: And this –
MR. CROWLEY: I’m not sure – what list is that?
QUESTION: This is for national security list and these reports have not been denied or rejected by Turkish –
MR. CROWLEY: I just don’t – I’m not familiar with whatever list you’re talking about. I mean, obviously we are very aware that there are tensions between two very close friends of the United States – Turkey and Israel. Their cooperation in the past has been very valuable to both countries, to the United States, and to the region. And we certainly hope that the two countries can find a way to resume that cooperation.
QUESTION: Do you have any information about the two hikers that are still in detention in Iran – their trial being moved, the date being moved?
MR. CROWLEY: I don’t know that we’ve been formally notified about that. Obviously, we believe that the hikers should be released and not put on trial.
QUESTION: P.J., I think there was something – forgive me that I don’t have all the details – but that the mothers are now going to be permitted to talk to their sons. It just came out this morning. Is that – are you aware of any –
MR. CROWLEY: We would obviously welcome that opportunity.
QUESTION: But you’re not aware of that?
MR. CROWLEY: We consult with the families on a regular basis. I just can’t say whether we – when the last time that we have chatted with the mothers.
QUESTION: Same subject, P.J.
MR. CROWLEY: Yeah.
QUESTION: Same subject P.J. – one of the reports today suggested that Sarah Shourd is considering returning to Iran for a trial. I’m just wondering what advice is the Department of State giving?
MR. CROWLEY: We’ll leave that advice private.
QUESTION: Regarding the Omar Khadr case, can you tell me what if any interaction or communication there was between the Canadian and U.S. Governments on the deal that was reached --
MR. CROWLEY: Well, we are --
QUESTION: -- or announced on the weekend?
MR. CROWLEY: The plea bargain was worked out between the prosecutors within the military commission and Omar Khadr’s defense lawyers. But it – the State Department was in touch with the Canadian Government and there was an exchange of diplomatic notes that helped pave the way for that plea bargain.
MR. CROWLEY: Well, Canada is aware of the details of the plea bargain, but as I think Canadian officials have made clear, this is – this, up until now, has been a matter between the United States Government and Mr. Khadr through the military commission’s process. Now, in the plea arrangement, Mr. Khadr will serve a year, at least a year, at Guantanamo. He has the option during that time to petition for a transfer to Canada. As Canada has indicated, there’s been no application yet and it will consider that application should it be made.
QUESTION: What was Secretary Clinton’s role in all this negotiating?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, as we mentioned, she did have a conversation with Foreign Minister Cannon. There needed to be an exchange of diplomatic notes to help with the plea arrangement. And following her conversation with Foreign Minister Cannon, there was that exchange of diplomatic notes.
QUESTION: P.J., Russian President Dmitriy Medvedev visited Japanese Northern Territory island, and such a high-level visit is the first time through Soviet Union era. And can I have the United States response, and do you recognize Japanese sovereignty over the islands?
MR. CROWLEY: We are quite aware of the dispute. We do back Japan regarding the Northern Territories. But this is why the United States, for a number of years, has encouraged Japan and Russia to negotiate an actual peace treaty regarding these and other issues.
QUESTION: In terms of Senkaku Island, Secretary Clinton just made it clear that it is within U.S.-Japan security treaty, and that is because the islands are controlled by Japan. And in terms of Northern Territories, where does the United States stand? Is it applied to United States and Japan security treaty, Article 5?
MR. CROWLEY: That’s a good question. I’ll take that question.
QUESTION: For the church bomb or church attack that happened yesterday, there are reports that it was handled – that rescue was handled pretty poorly for the hostages. So do you have any comment at this time for how it went down?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, this was an action led by the Iraqi security forces, and I’ll defer to them.
MR. CROWLEY: Well, actually, we – the Secretary was in Bosnia recently. We’ve been significantly engaged with our European partners, have had many, many conversations, many trips by the Secretary, by the Deputy Secretary and others. We are trying to move Bosnia to a point where it is fully integrated, both as a country and then within Europe. We have supported a process by which Bosnia has the option of joining NATO down the road, but rather than predicting its demise, we hope that Bosnia will advance and become a full participant in the European Union.
QUESTION: On General Gration’s trip to Sudan, I’m wondering if you can give us an update on the talks that they, I guess, have been having over the last couple of days. Has there been any progress, particularly on the Abyei issue?
MR. CROWLEY: Nothing I can point to. I mean, that’s why he’s going to Juba tomorrow. He’s, along with former South African President Thabo Mbeki. They’ve been talking to officials in Khartoum. We will – we’ll have similar conversations with Southern Sudan officials. We continue to believe that a successful referendum on Abyei can be accomplished in early January on schedule, but clearly, the parties need to come together, make some decisions, and then take the appropriate actions to prepare not only for that referendum but also the one regarding South Sudan.
QUESTION: The Southern Sudanese officials are saying that the U.S. has suggested a way forward whereby they would annex Abyei and then give the North basically financial restitution. This is a U.S. suggestion that’s on the table. Can you confirm that?
MR. CROWLEY: No.
QUESTION: Do you think it would be a good idea? Is that one way out of this?
MR. CROWLEY: I think that we’ll keep our discussions with officials at this point confidential.
QUESTION: But is –
MR. CROWLEY: I’m not – don’t take that to mean I’m confirming what you just suggested.
MR. CROWLEY: I’m sorry, start again.
QUESTION: It is a report Secretary Clinton asked China to prevent any provocative action by North Korea during G-20 Summit. What’s the U.S. position on that?
MR. CROWLEY: Well, let’s not limit it the G-20. We are interested in seeing North Korea cease all provocative actions of all kinds for any point going forward. We do have ongoing concerns about North Korean provocations and we do it – we have discussed this with China and encouraged China to have appropriate conversations with North Korea.
QUESTION: (Inaudible) same question. I mean, she asked a very direct question about the G-20. Are there particular concerns about that?
MR. CROWLEY: I haven’t gotten a lengthy readout yet of the Secretary’s conversations with either Foreign Minister Yang or Chairman Dai. So I – but it would not surprise me that we had – when we talk to China about North Korea, we tend to mention our concerns about North Korean provocations.
QUESTION: Did you get a reply to your tweet to Iranian president on his birthday?
MR. CROWLEY: I got a lot of replies to my tweet. (Laughter.) Not from Iran.
QUESTION: Haiti – do you have any update from last week’s – excuse me – about the reconstruction funds not being ready?
MR. CROWLEY: Yeah. This just in. Not quite done. We’re still – we have a – (laughter). We have one more reporting requirement we’ve got to get through.
QUESTION: Just another – can I have one other Haiti question real quickly?
MR. CROWLEY: Sure.
QUESTION: There were these suggestions last week that the cholera may have been brought in by Nepalese soldiers. CDC is now reporting that it is from South Asia, and I wonder if you’ve been satisfied with the way the UN has looked into this.
MR. CROWLEY: I believe that is still a matter that’s under investigation.
QUESTION: Thank you.
MR. CROWLEY: Thank you.
(The briefing was concluded at 2:13 p.m.)
DPB # 179