Transparency of the Regulatory System
Iraq’s overall regulatory environment remains opaque. Corruption, unclear regulations, and bureaucratic bottlenecks are major challenges for investors that bid on public procurement contracts or seek to invest in major infrastructure projects. The KRG rolled out procurement reform measures in 2016 that seek to address some of these issues, yet the efficacy of these measures remains unclear. Iraq’s commercial and civil laws generally fall short of international norms. There are few provisions regarding commercial competition. The NIL does not establish a full legal framework governing investment.
The absence of other laws in areas of interest to foreign investors also creates ambiguity. Iraq’s Legislative Action Plan for the Implementation of WTO Agreements – the legislative “road map” for Iraq’s eventual WTO accession – requires competition and consumer protection laws that are critical for leveling the business playing field. The Council of Representatives passed a Competition Law and a Consumer Protection Law in 2010; however, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commissions authorized by these laws have yet to be formed. Without these Commissions, investors do not have recourse against unfair business practices such as bid rigging or abuse of a dominant position in the market.
The way in which the Iraqi government promulgates regulations can be opaque and lends itself to arbitrary use. Regulations imposing duties on citizens or private businesses are required to be published in the official government gazette. However, there is no corresponding requirement for the publication of internal ministerial regulations. This loophole allows bureaucrats to create internal requirements or procedures with little or no oversight, which can result in additional burdens for investors and other businesspersons.
Accounting, legal, and regulatory procedures are opaque, inconsistent, and generally do not meet international standards. Draft bills, including investment laws, are not available for public comment.
The GOI encourages private sector associations but private sector associations are generally not influential, given the dominant role of SOEs in Iraq’s economy.
Investors sometimes find it challenging to deconflict seemingly opposing regulations from relevant stakeholder ministries and investment entities. The promulgation of new regulations with little advance notice and requirements related to investment guarantees have also slowed projects. While the KRIL does not stipulate that a local partner is necessary to acquire an investment license, government officials sometimes encourage this practice.
Legal System and Judicial Independence
Iraq has a civil law system, although Iraqi commercial jurisprudence is relatively underdeveloped. During decades of war and sanctions, Iraqi courts became isolated from developments in international commercial transactions. Corruption and bureaucratic bottlenecks remain significant problems. As trade with foreign parties increases, Iraqi courts have seen a significant increase in complex commercial cases. Contracts should be enforceable under Iraqi law. In practice, however, honoring contracts and contract enforcement remains a challenge due to unclear regulations, lack of decision-making authority, and rampant corruption.
In November 2010, Iraq’s Higher Judicial Council established the First Commercial Court of Iraq, a court of specialized jurisdiction for disputes involving foreign investors as part of a national strategy to improve Iraq’s investment climate. This court began hearing cases in January 2011. It has jurisdiction only over cases involving foreign parties in Baghdad province. The court received 5 cases in 2015 and over 500 cases since its establishment. Over 350 of these cases have been adjudicated, many in as few as 30 days, since the judges are able to give their full attention to these cases. This record stands in stark contrast to general jurisdiction trial courts that receive up to 30 cases per day and do not give priority to commercial cases, thereby causing commercial cases to be delayed for months or years before a resolution is achieved. Iraqi judicial officials have since created two additional commercial courts in Najaf and Basrah. Given that all of Iraq’s ministries are located in the capital, and the vast majority of commercial cases involve a foreign party and an Iraqi government agency, the Baghdad Commercial Court reviews far more commercial cases than the general jurisdiction courts in the surrounding provinces. In the IKR, commercial disputes are handled through the civil court system.
Iraq is a signatory to the League of Arab States Convention on Commercial Arbitration (1987) and the Riyadh Convention on Judicial Cooperation (1983). Iraq formally joined the ICSID Convention on December 17, 2015, and on February 18th, 2017, Iraq joined Investor-state Dispute Settlement (ISDS) process agreement between investors and states.
Additional information can be found in “A Legal Guide to Investing in Iraq:” http://cldp.doc.gov/programs/cldp-in-action/details/1551
Laws and Regulations on Foreign Direct Investment
The NIL, amended in December 2015, provides a legal structure to protect foreign and domestic investors while also providing investment incentives. It allows both domestic and foreign investors to qualify for investment incentives equally; however, tax exemption periods are longer if the project is over 50 percent Iraqi-owned. A 2015 amendment to the NIL allows foreign ownership of land for the purpose of developing residential real estate projects. For industrial projects, foreign ownership of land is allowed if jointly owned by an Iraqi partner. Although the NIL was meant to clarify and codify investment regulations, the lack of clear and definitive implementing mechanisms creates confusion and delays in the approval of investment projects. Furthermore, the NIL does not absolve any investor from fully adhering to the requirements and mechanisms of other laws, as well as any legal requirement applicable under Iraqi law as a whole. (A copy of the amended 2015 NIL can be obtained from the National Investment Commission website http://investpromo.gov.iq/policies-and-laws/ .)
The NIL does not apply to investment in the IKR. Under the Iraqi Constitution, some issues relevant to the overall investment climate are either shared by the federal government and the regions or are devolved entirely to the regions. Currently, the IKR, comprising four northern provinces, is the only area of Iraq with a designation as a region. Investment in the IKR operates within the framework of the Kurdistan Region Investment Law (KRIL) of 2006 and the Kurdistan Board of Investment (KBOI), which is designed to provide incentives to help economic development in areas under the authority of the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG).
The KRIL provides specific incentives for companies to develop strategic investment projects, which the KBOI evaluates and licenses based on the project’s perceived economic and environmental impacts. If approved, a company is awarded an investment license that could include free land, a ten-year exemption from corporate taxes, and a five-year exemption from customs duties on raw materials. The KBOI has approved 750 projects since 2006. Investors who do not wish to receive the incentives for their projects under the investment law may invest without applying for the investment license by working directly with the relevant sector’s ministry. A copy of the IKR Investment Law can be obtained from the KBOI website:http://www.kurdistaninvestment.org/docs/Investment%20Law.pdf.
A list and comprehensive review of Iraqi laws relevant to the Investment Process is included in “A Legal Guide to Investing in Iraq,” a collaboration between the U.S. Department of Commerce’s Commercial Law Development Program (CLDP) and the National Investment Commission (NIC): http://cldp.doc.gov/programs/cldp-in-action/details/1551
Competition and Anti-Trust Laws
The Council of Representatives passed a Competition Law and a Consumer Protection Law in 2010. However, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commissions authorized by these laws have yet to be formed. The NIL is supposed to promote fair competition and “competitive capacities” in the local market. However, the NIL does not include specific competition legislation. The prominent role of SOEs in Iraq and corruption issues undermine the competitive landscape.
Expropriation and Compensation
Article 23 of the Iraqi Constitution prohibits expropriation in Iraq, unless done for the purpose of public benefit and in return for just compensation. The Constitution stipulates that expropriation may be regulated by law, but specific legislation regarding expropriation has not been drafted. Article 9 of the amended NIL also guarantees non-seizure or nationalization of any investment project covered by the provisions of this law, except in the cases where an absolute judicial judgment has been reached. It prohibits expropriation of an investment project, except in cases of public benefit and with fair compensation. Iraq’s Commercial Court is charged with resolving expropriation cases. Over the past six years, there have not been any government actions or shifts in government policy that would indicate possible expropriations in the foreseeable future.
In the IKR, if the KBOI determines that investors are using land awarded under investment licenses for purposes other than those outlined in the license, it can impose fines and potentially confiscate the land. Article 17 of the IKR investment law outlines an investor’s arbitration rights, which fall under the civil court system. Arbitration clauses should be written into local contracts in order to facilitate enforcement in the event of a dispute.
Dispute Settlement
Iraq has a civil law system, although Iraqi commercial jurisprudence is relatively underdeveloped. During decades of war and sanctions, Iraqi courts became isolated from developments in international commercial transactions. Corruption and bureaucratic bottlenecks remain significant problems. As trade with foreign parties increases, Iraqi courts have seen a significant increase in complex commercial cases. Contracts should be enforceable under Iraqi law. In practice, however, honoring contracts and contract enforcement remains a challenge due to unclear regulations, lack of decision-making authority, and rampant corruption.
In November 2010, Iraq’s Higher Judicial Council established the First Commercial Court of Iraq, a court of specialized jurisdiction for disputes involving foreign investors as part of a national strategy to improve Iraq’s investment climate. This court began hearing cases in January 2011. It has jurisdiction only over cases involving foreign parties in Baghdad province. The court received 5 cases in 2015 and over 500 cases since its establishment. Over 350 of these cases have been adjudicated, many in as few as 30 days, since the judges are able to give their full attention to these cases. This record stands in stark contrast to general jurisdiction trial courts that receive up to 30 cases per day and do not give priority to commercial cases, thereby causing commercial cases to be delayed for months or years before a resolution is achieved. Iraqi judicial officials have since created two additional commercial courts in Najaf and Basrah. Given that all of Iraq’s ministries are located in the capital, and the vast majority of commercial cases involve a foreign party and an Iraqi government agency, the Baghdad Commercial Court reviews far more commercial cases than the general jurisdiction courts in the surrounding provinces. In the IKR, commercial disputes are handled through the civil court system.
Iraq is a signatory to the League of Arab States Convention on Commercial Arbitration (1987) and the Riyadh Convention on Judicial Cooperation (1983). Iraq formally joined the ICSID Convention on December 17, 2015, and on February 18th, 2017, Iraq joined Investor-state Dispute Settlement (ISDS) process agreement between investors and states.
Iraq is considering, but has not yet signed or ratified, the convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958 New York Convention) and the ad hoc arbitration rules and procedures established by the UN Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL Model Law). The enforcement of arbitral awards must comply with the special requirements set forth in current Iraqi civil procedure law and other related laws.
Additional information can be found in “A Legal Guide to Investing in Iraq:” http://cldp.doc.gov/programs/cldp-in-action/details/1551
Bankruptcy Regulations
Under Iraqi law, an Iraqi debtor may file for bankruptcy, and an Iraqi creditor may file for liquidation of the debtor. Bankruptcy is not criminalized. The Iraqi Companies Law regulates the process for liquidation of legal entities. Nevertheless, the mechanism for resolving insolvency remains opaque. Iraq ranks 169 out of 190 countries in the category of Resolving Insolvency, according to the World Bank’s 2017 Doing Business Report.