Transparency of the Regulatory System
National legislation is enacted by the Parliament and President. The government, ministries, and local executive administrations issue regulations and executive acts in compliance with national laws. Publicly listed companies adhere to international financial reporting standards, but accounting and valuation practices are not always consistent with international best practices. The government does not require companies to disclose environmental, social, and governance (ESG) data. Companies listed on the Kazakhstan Stock Exchange (KASE) and Astana International Exchange (AIX), must, however, disclose information on ESG. The 2022 ESG Index ranks Kazakhstan 53rd out 183, with low level of risk.
All laws and decrees of the President and the government are available in Kazakh and Russian on the websites of the Ministry of Justice: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus and http://zan.gov.kz/en/ . The government consults on some draft legislation with experts and the business community; draft bills are available for public comment at https://legalacts.egov.kz under the Open Government section. The process of public comments seems overregulated. Publication occurs without broad notifications, some bills are excluded from public comment, and those who want to participate must register in advance.
Implementation and interpretation of commercial legislation sometimes creates confusion. In 2016, the Ministry of Health and Social Development introduced new rules on attracting foreign labor, some of which created significant barriers for foreign investors. After active intervention through the Prime Minister’s Council, the government canceled the most onerous requirements. Decrees and legislative changes frequently do not “grandfather in” existing investments. Penalties are often assessed for periods prior to the change in policy.
The 2021 OECD-compliant Environmental Code (Eco Code) mandates that local authorities spend 100 percent of environmental payments on environmental remediation.
The government began drafting a new Tax Code in late 2022 that is planned to be enacted in 2024. The government pledged to discuss openly the bill and to take into account recommendations from the local business community, foreign investors, and experts.
Public financial reporting, including debt obligations, are published by the National Bank of Kazakhstan at https://nationalbank.kz/en/news/vneshniy-dolg and by the Ministry of Finance on its site:
https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/minfin/documents/details/454407?directionId=261&lang=ru
International Regulatory Considerations
Eurasian Economic Integration and WTO
Kazakhstan is a founding member of the EAEU, created in 2014, with Armenia, Belarus, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Russia. The EAEU is designed to further integrate the economies of its member states, and to provide for the free movement of services, capital, and labor within their common territory. EAEU regulations and decisions supersede the national regulatory system. The GOK asserts that EAEU agreements comply with WTO standards. However, since joining the Customs Union, Kazakhstan doubled its average import tariff and introduced annual tariff-rate quotas (TRQs) on poultry, beef, and pork. Per its WTO commitments, Kazakhstan lowered 3,512 import tariff rates to an average of 4.3 percent in December 2021. Now, Kazakhstan is preparing for negotiations on countervailing measures, which planned for 2024.
Kazakhstan notifies the WTO Committee on Technical Barriers to Trade about drafts of national technical regulations, although Embassy staff have noted lapses sometimes. Kazakhstan ratified the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) and completed its TFA commitments in 2018.
Impact of Russia’s Aggression Against Ukraine on Kazakhstan’s Economy
Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine affected Kazakhstan’s economic relationships with Russia and Belarus, complicated external trade, and business operations, and caused supply chain disruptions. Kazakhstan’s businesses must conduct greater due diligence when working with Russian business partners, exporting to, or transshipping products through Russia and Belarus, or transmitting payments. Sanctions have affected trade routes transiting Russia, increasing demand in Kazakhstan for alternative shipping routes such as via the Trans-Caspian International Transport Route (TITR). Inflation in Kazakhstan reached 21.3 percent year-on-year in February 2023 and the currency initially lost significant value against the dollar due to its close connection with the Russian ruble but has since rebounded.
International oil companies (IOCs) reported sanctions-related risks of disruption, reduction, temporary suspension, or limitation of shipments via the Caspian Pipeline Consortium pipeline (CPC)through Russia. Kazakhstan’s national oil company KazMunayGas (KMG) postponed drilling works at the Zhenis offshore block due to a sanctions-related delay of delivery of equipment. Metal mining companies also reported issues with delivery of necessary materials because foreign ships will not enter Russian seaports. Disruptions in supply of spare parts from Ukraine has also impacted extractive industries.
Kazakhstan’s oil, uranium, and metals companies are increasingly using alternate routes that bypass Russia, such as receiving fuel shipments through in seaports in Georgia, Latvia, and Estonia; redirecting a small amount of oil exports from the CPC pipeline to Caspian seaports; and using TITR for some uranium shipments.
Seeking to distinguish its exports from oil originating in Russia, Kazakhstan introduced its own Kazakhstan Export Blend Crude Oil (KEBCO) in June 2022 and managed to decrease the spread with Brent Crude. KMG introduced sanctions disclaimers to its legal documents to allow for a withdrawal of sanctioned Russian companies from joint projects.
Sanctions also affected Kazakhstan’s banking sector (see Section 6 for details).
However, Kazakhstan’s trade in 2022 reportedly benefitted from sanctions on Russia, earning 40 percent more on exports as commodity prices increased. The country started to sell to seven new markets and expanded the types of products exported. Kazakhstan doubled its alumina exports to Russia, but its exports of iron ore to Russia dropped by 70 percent. Restrictions introduced by the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) on processing Russian gold also affected Kazakhstan’s gold refining companies, which are certified with LBMA.
The GOK has made a clear commitment to abide by the sanction and export control regimes. On March 1, 2023, the GOK enacted a new Law on Control of Specific Goods, which defined principles and the legal basis of trade in dual-use goods and defense articles. The law cancelled an old law on export control and determined the order of control over identification, export, import, transit, and movement of specific goods across the border, as well as areas of responsibilities of individuals and legal entities while exporting, importing, reexporting, and transiting specific goods. Technologies, materials, and software that can be used for both civil and military purposes are considered specific goods by law.
On April 1, Kazakhstan introduced an online system for tracking of goods. Customs authorities will now require accompanying electronic invoices for all goods to be traded with EAEU member-states.
Legal System and Judicial Independence
The Civil Code establishes commercial and contract law principles. The judicial system is officially independent of the executive branch, although the government interferes in judiciary matters. Freedom House’s 2022 Nations in Transit report gave Kazakhstan a very low score (1.25 out of seven) in the Judicial Framework and Independence category, implying that the executive branch effectively dominates the judicial branch. Allegations of pervasive corruption of the courts and the influence of the ruling elite results in low public expectations and trust in the justice system.
The country’s leadership recognizes the lack of judicial independence. In March 2023, the President enacted a law on reforming the judicial system by introducing a new mechanism for electing the chairmen of district courts and strengthening guarantees for the immunity of judges. Parties to commercial contracts, including foreign investors, can seek dispute settlement in Kazakhstan’s courts or international arbitration, and courts nominally enforce arbitration clauses in contracts. However, Post is aware of at least one case when the government is alleged to have refused to honor a fully litigated international arbitral decision.
The AIFC has its own arbitration center and court based on British Common Law and is independent of the judiciary. The government advises foreign investors to use the capacities of the AIFC arbitration center and the AIFC court more actively.
Laws and Regulations on Foreign Direct Investment
Laws provide for non-expropriation, currency convertibility, guarantees of legal stability, transparent government procurement, and incentives for priority sectors. The Entrepreneurial Code outlines basic principles of doing business, the government’s relations with entrepreneurs, and codifies non-discrimination for foreign investors. The code contains incentives and preferences for government-determined priority sectors.
A law on Currency Regulation and Currency Control expands the statistical monitoring of transactions in foreign currency and facilitated the process of de-dollarization. The law treats branches of foreign companies in Kazakhstan as residents and enables the National Bank of Kazakhstan (NBK) to enhance control over cross-border transactions.
The government’s single window for foreign investors, providing information to potential investors, business registration, and links to relevant legislation, can be found here: https://invest.gov.kz/invest-guide/
Competition and Antitrust Laws
The Entrepreneurial Code regulates competition-related issues such as cartel agreements and unfair competition. The Agency for Protection and Development of Competition is responsible for reviewing transactions for competition-related concerns. Regulation of natural monopolies remains with the Ministry of National Economy. In January 2022, the President signed into law amendments introducing new antimonopoly concepts and best practices, including anti-monopoly compliance. After January 2022 events, the government created the Commission on Demonopolization, which is aimed at reducing the role of oligopolies in the economy and providing policy recommendations on the possible nationalization of assets that the government now considers to have been illegally privatized.
Expropriation and Compensation
The bilateral investment treaty between the United States and Kazakhstan requires the government to provide compensation in the event of expropriation. The Entrepreneurial Code allows the state to nationalize property in emergency cases but fails to provide clear criteria for expropriation or to require prompt and adequate compensation at fair market value.
The Mission is aware of cases where owners of flourishing and developed businesses have been forced to sell their businesses to companies affiliated with high-ranking and powerful individuals. In 2021, the government amended the Criminal Code and enhanced punishment for raiding by increasing the possible sentence to a range of five to eight years.
One hydrocarbons company claims expropriation. The case went to international arbitration and the legal process continues without resolution.
The government did not introduce confiscatory tax regimes or regulatory actions against investors. Under an ongoing campaign on de-monopolization (see Competition and Antitrust Laws section), some oligarchs returned assets to the state in the form of a donation. However, when individuals are indicted for embezzlement or money laundering, the government seizes their assets by court rulings (see section 9).
Dispute Settlement
ICSID Convention and New York Convention
Kazakhstan is a member of the International Center for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), a tribunal applying the rules of the UN Commission on International Trade Law Arbitration. The country has also ratified the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. Any international award rendered by the ICSID, Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, London Court of International Arbitration, or Arbitration Commission at the Kazakhstan Chamber of Commerce and Industry is enforceable. The government does not always honor such awards.
Investor-State Dispute Settlement
The bilateral investment agreements recognize international arbitration of investment disputes.
The Entrepreneurial Code states that investment disputes may be settled in accordance with negotiation, litigation, or arbitration.
Kazakhstan is legally obligated to recognize arbitral awards yet does not always do so. In February 2022, the Ministry of Justice reported about 25 pending arbitration proceedings, including 14 in international arbitration courts. The GOK is a respondent to one pending case in the ICSID initiated by foreign claimants. Several investment disputes involving foreign companies have arisen in the past several years linked to alleged violations of environmental regulations, tax laws, transfer pricing laws, and investment clauses. Problems arise in the enforcement of judgments, and ample opportunity exists for influencing judicial outcomes given the relative lack of judicial independence.
The government has developed a dispute resolution mechanism aimed at enabling aggrieved investors to seek redress without requiring them to litigate their claims. The government established an Investment Ombudsman in 2013 and in 2019 designated the Prime Minister to act in this role. However, investors who have entered such settlement discussions in good faith report that on at least one occasion the government pursued criminal litigation just as the parties were closing in on a deal (after the investors had devoted significant time and resources toward achieving a settlement).
International Commercial Arbitration and Foreign Courts
The Law on Mediation offers alternative (non-litigated) dispute resolutions and defines rules and principles of domestic arbitration. Kazakhstan has 17 local arbitration bodies unified under the Arbitration Chamber and 14 additional unaffiliated arbitration bodies. Please see:
https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/adilet/documents/details/336759?directionId=259&lang=ru
The Law on Arbitration brought the national arbitration legislation into compliance with the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) Model Law, the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, and the European Convention on International Commercial Arbitration. Judgement of other foreign state courts are recognized and enforceable by local courts when there is a bilateral agreement on mutual judicial assistance with the respective country or applies a principle of reciprocity.
The AIFC’s International Arbitration Center (IAC) is not regulated by the Law on Arbitration. For details on the IAC’s operations, please see: https://iac.aifc.kz/en .
When SOEs are involved in investment disputes, domestic courts usually find in the SOE’s favor.
The country’s authorities acknowledge that local courts lack experience with commercial law. In response to criticism from President Tokayev in 2021, the Supreme Court undertook steps to improve to improve selection of judges and development of their professional skills.
Bankruptcy Regulations
Bankruptcy Law protects the rights of creditors during insolvency proceedings. Bankruptcy is not criminalized, unless the court determines the bankruptcy was premeditated, or rehabilitation measures were wrongful. The law eases bureaucratic requirements for bankruptcy filings, gives creditors a greater say in continuing operations, introduces a time limit for adopting rehabilitation or reorganization plans, and adds court supervision requirements.
In March 2023, Kazakhstan enacted new legislation introducing individual bankruptcy in response to increasing numbers of insolvent debtors from vulnerable populations.